Ombudsman Criticizes Amnesty International’s Stance on Ruben Vardanyan Case

Baku: Azerbaijani Commissioner for Human Rights (Ombudsman) Sabina Aliyeva has criticized a statement by Marie Struhers, Amnesty International's Director for Eastern Europe and Central Asia, concerning the conviction of Ruben Vardanyan, an Armenian citizen. Vardanyan was found guilty of several severe charges, including crimes against peace and humanity, war crimes, terrorism, and financing terrorism.

According to Azerbaijan State News Agency, Aliyeva emphasized that the trial against Vardanyan was conducted openly and in accordance with international judicial practices at the Baku Military Court. The trial, attended by the accused, his defense, victims, their legal successors, and representatives, received extensive media coverage. Vardanyan was ultimately sentenced to 20 years in prison for the charges against him.

Aliyeva argued that Amnesty International's statement on the court's verdict was legally and morally incorrect, non-objective, and biased. She stated that the claims contradict international legal documents, noting that individuals with similar charges during historical conflicts have not been similarly protected. Aliyeva criticized the organization's approach as inconsistent with the principles of objectivity and professional ethics required for international non-governmental organizations.

Aliyeva further highlighted that the statement by Amnesty International demonstrates a biased stance and double standards against Azerbaijan. She pointed out that the organization's selective approach and decontextualized facts raise questions about its funding sources and political influences.

From a legal standpoint, Aliyeva asserted that the charges against Vardanyan align with both Azerbaijani national laws and international legal norms, supported by concrete evidence. She assured that throughout the investigation and trial, Vardanyan's defense rights were fully protected, with legal counsel provided and opportunities to participate in proceedings ensured.

The Ombudsman's Office, which includes the National Preventive Group, monitored the detention conditions and treatment of Vardanyan and other Armenian-origin individuals. These activities adhered to international standards, with rights and freedoms explained in their native language and health checks conducted.

Aliyeva concluded by urging Amnesty International to abandon its biased approach, refrain from politicizing legal matters, and adhere to objective, balanced, and professional principles in human rights advocacy. She emphasized that legitimacy in international human rights advocacy relies on a foundation of facts, law, and justice.